Chinese Canadian Artifacts Project

Item SMA-SR-2015-018 - Newspaper Article - 7 August 1919 - on Asian immigration

Title and statement of responsibility area

Title proper

Newspaper Article - 7 August 1919 - on Asian immigration

General material designation

  • Textual record

Parallel title

Other title information

Title statements of responsibility

Title notes

Level of description


Reference code

CA SMA SMA-SR-2015-018

Edition area

Edition statement

Edition statement of responsibility

Class of material specific details area

Statement of scale (cartographic)

Statement of projection (cartographic)

Statement of coordinates (cartographic)

Statement of scale (architectural)

Issuing jurisdiction and denomination (philatelic)

Dates of creation area


Physical description area

Physical description

Publisher's series area

Title proper of publisher's series

Parallel titles of publisher's series

Other title information of publisher's series

Statement of responsibility relating to publisher's series

Numbering within publisher's series

Note on publisher's series

Archival description area

Custodial history

Scope and content

Sidney and Islands Review, "The Review's Oriental Policy", 7 August 1919, Page 3.

"The Review's Oriental Policy
The attitude of The Review on the Oriental question should by this time be well known. We have on several occasions published editorials expressing our conviction that British Columbia would be better off without Japanese, Chinese and Hindus. We believe industrial, civic and educational conditions would be improved, and that prohibition of Oriental immigration and ownership would do much for the development of the Province.
But it must be borne in mind that the present beads of industries are not entirely to blame for present conditions, some of them not to blame at all. Oriental labor was imported by the big interests, whose only motive was to cheapen production. After the Chinese, Japs and Hindus were here they were confronted with the necessity of making a living, and they entered into competition with white men in the logging camps, in the mills, the fisheries and wherever they could find employment. They worked for lower wages, and without realizing the far-reaching deleterious results of the advent of Asiatic labor to the local market, the industries hired them.
The problem which now confronts many of the captains of industry is how to get rid of the Oriental and still continue to operate industry at a profit. For one mill or one cannery to employ whites to the exclusion of Orientals while other plants in the same line of business continue to use Oriental labor at reduced wages, means that the institution using only white labor must cease to complete. It is patent that for any single plant among the industries employing Orientals to shift at once to white labor at a wage increase of say 40 per cent, would mean financial disaster for that plant. Unless in place of the discharged Oriental hands the newly employed white hands gave it a very material increase in quantity of production. We hear a great deal said about how much more the white man can do than the Oriental, and while we fully believe that the white man is incomparably more intelligent, more energetic and more efficient, we beg to point out that tabulated comparative results along this line are practically non-existent, and that the average employer making a change from Oriental to white labor would be working largely in the dark.
Clearly, for one captain of industry to oust the Oriental without his associates doing the same could have but the result of putting that man's industry out of business. The Asiatic cannot be gotten rid of without concerted action; and concerted action is an impossibility without unamimity of opinion. It would appear that the problem is not one for the captains of industry but for the people to solve. Orientals were permitted to be imported to the Province because there were no prohibitive statutes on the civil code. The people have the power, through intelligent use of the plebiscite, to provide for the enactment of such laws as are needed, and not only to prohibit Oriental immigration, but to eject Orientals already here. The solution of the problem lies not in howling about the employers and the newspapers which are supposed to side with them, but in intelligent and unanimous action at the polls. When Oriental labor is excluded by law the problem will be solved, but not before. When conditions are such that employment of white lobor exclusively does not work a hardship upon industry, white labor will be exclusively employed. It is up to the people."

Notes area

Physical condition

Immediate source of acquisition

Transcription from scan of original by Brad Morrison, 2015


Language of material

Script of material

Location of originals

Availability of other formats

Restrictions on access

Terms governing use, reproduction, and publication

Finding aids

Associated materials

Related materials


Alternative identifier(s)

Standard number area

Standard number

Access points

Subject access points

Place access points

Name access points

Genre access points

Control area

Description record identifier

Institution identifier

Rules or conventions


Level of detail

Dates of creation, revision and deletion

Language of description

Script of description


Digital object metadata



Media type





1008.8 KiB


September 27, 2015 10:12 AM

Digital object (Master) rights area

Digital object (Reference) rights area

Digital object (Thumbnail) rights area

Accession area

Related subjects

Related people and organizations

Related places

Related genres